An IITD student/alumnus reading this would understand what this means when I say the BRCA (Board for Recreational and Cultural Activities) trophy has been scrapped this year. That includes THE trophy, all club trophies and awards. Whether this will be a permanent phenomenon or trigger a change in future regulations, only the next few months will tell, but for this year for sure, the game's over.
To be frank, it wasn't entirely unexpected. When I look back at the events of the past year, things have been controversy-marred and awfully unhealthy. The actions of a handful of hostels have turned a fun, recreational, exciting place into an ultracompetitive unsporting fanaticism gradually over the last two yrs, but everything this year was just unpalatable. So today when the profs handed out the non-negotiable verdict, it seemed harsh n sudden, but it was probably the right thing to do. Honestly, RCA has lost its appeal for a lot of us for the sheer point crazy madness that prevails at events these days. The number of events were reduced to reduce pressure, but instead they've made every event a do-or-die affair, in the process killing fun and spirit first. And IITians being IITians, and RCA trophy being the Nobel of IIT stay, things got too competitive too soon. And shamefully, unethical too.
Still, for someone like me who saw the glorious days with twice as many events enjoyed harmoniously each year, for someone like me who inherited the culture of exploring talents , learning by competing and bonding with people genuinely interested in the same things as you, this marks a moment when things at IIT might just change forever hereon, to what we grew up with. There used to be small controversies on and off earlier, but most were hushed, well taken care of and more the exception than the rule. This year, the mud-slinging has been dirty and out in the open. I didn't enjoy one event all year.
I just wanna hope that this action puts things in perspective and at the right place. Let people realise what's really important, and even if the trophy is permanently scrapped (And I hope it takes BSP and BSW trophies along) I am optimistic for a smaller, nicer RCA with people who do things they enjoy, for the sake of the fun and the people, and not for a shiny piece of metal. But alongwith the optimism, there's a tinge of grief at what inevitably looks like the final nail in the coffin for an era.
To be frank, it wasn't entirely unexpected. When I look back at the events of the past year, things have been controversy-marred and awfully unhealthy. The actions of a handful of hostels have turned a fun, recreational, exciting place into an ultracompetitive unsporting fanaticism gradually over the last two yrs, but everything this year was just unpalatable. So today when the profs handed out the non-negotiable verdict, it seemed harsh n sudden, but it was probably the right thing to do. Honestly, RCA has lost its appeal for a lot of us for the sheer point crazy madness that prevails at events these days. The number of events were reduced to reduce pressure, but instead they've made every event a do-or-die affair, in the process killing fun and spirit first. And IITians being IITians, and RCA trophy being the Nobel of IIT stay, things got too competitive too soon. And shamefully, unethical too.
Still, for someone like me who saw the glorious days with twice as many events enjoyed harmoniously each year, for someone like me who inherited the culture of exploring talents , learning by competing and bonding with people genuinely interested in the same things as you, this marks a moment when things at IIT might just change forever hereon, to what we grew up with. There used to be small controversies on and off earlier, but most were hushed, well taken care of and more the exception than the rule. This year, the mud-slinging has been dirty and out in the open. I didn't enjoy one event all year.
I just wanna hope that this action puts things in perspective and at the right place. Let people realise what's really important, and even if the trophy is permanently scrapped (And I hope it takes BSP and BSW trophies along) I am optimistic for a smaller, nicer RCA with people who do things they enjoy, for the sake of the fun and the people, and not for a shiny piece of metal. But alongwith the optimism, there's a tinge of grief at what inevitably looks like the final nail in the coffin for an era.
8 comments:
As much as i loved being a part of the competition but even i have to agree things have gone awfully wrong this year, the two hostels have absolutely gone crazy.... dont know what more will happen now :(
if senior most students have intervened at right time this could have been avoided.
definitely not a IITD alumni....but I still hope that things change for the better..
Cheers
Boy, this was going to happen one day or the other. And somehow, it's shameful that it has come to this.
Any details on what caused this? I've been out for two years and have no clue what's been up.
To me inter-hostel rivalry always looked futile (though it certainly brought out the best in many). Throughout my four years the competition was always too aggressive and usually too much for me to handle. So I'm not surprised by the Professors' decision.
That's why I loved non-comps!
Also, at the risk of not knowing what actually happened, I would say that throwing the blame on a handful of hostels may not be right. If that were the case the hostels in question would have certainly been banned. I think the system had some inherent flaws for quite some time, and the deciding body clearly took notice.
-- Anjul
I must be the last person saying this... but its time to revaluate the credit ratings.
[UC]
Yeah, I totally agree. I hope it somehow makes ppl to rethink n eliminate poltu out of the sphere.
[voice]
The fourth yr, which is for all practical purposes the seniormost and the most authoritative, has been responsible for this...or at lst elements from among them. What cd have happened?
[kunnu]
:) hope so
[natansh]
Very shameful...
[AP]
Loadsa details, but kinda not the place to give it in detail..basical two strong hostels vying for the trophy led to 2 political alliances n then the bottom fell out from competitiveness leading to RCA and BSW trophies being scrapped. Everybody's hands dirty by the end..
[mostlybhu]
Indeed. And saner, hopefully.
Post a Comment